Watchtower
15 min read
Ron Helms

Six Days Short, Two Days Early, Page 4 of 2: Trinidad's Budget Paperwork Before Tuesday

Trinidad's October 27 budget hearing was noticed in the newspaper six days ahead when the law requires ten. Its notice for Tuesday was online two days before the date it certifies. A recap of what the City's own records show before Tuesday's budget vote.

In This Article10 sections · jump to any part

The newspaper notice for Trinidad's October 27 budget hearing ran six days before the hearing, and state law requires at least ten.[1][2] The notice for Tuesday's meeting says it was posted Thursday, November 12, but the City's own file server shows the signed copy went online Tuesday, November 10.[3][4]

This is a recap of what the City's own records show about its budget meetings, from October 27 to Tuesday's vote. Each finding comes with the way I checked it, so anyone can check it again.

Six Days Short

Word has reached me that some people are frustrated with me over the October 27 meeting ending before the budget vote. The record of how it ended is short.

Three of the Council's four seated aldermen were present that night, and the meeting was a called meeting. Under Local Government Code §22.039, a called meeting needs four.[5] I raised it during the public hearing. After checking the statute, the City Attorney said on the record, "since this is a special meeting, it appears that we do need it," and the Mayor ended the meeting.[6][7]

The hearing had a second problem that nobody raised that night. Local Government Code §102.0065 requires a city to publish notice of a budget hearing in a county newspaper "not earlier than the 30th or later than the 10th day before the date of the hearing."[2] For an October 27 hearing, the last day to publish was October 17. Trinidad's notice ran in the Athens Daily Review on Wednesday, October 21, six days before the hearing.[1] The Texas Press Association's public notice archive shows no other Trinidad budget hearing notice between September 17 and November 16, so the October 21 notice is the one on record.[1]

With or without a , the October 27 hearing was not noticed the way the budget law requires.

The same night, the Mayor read the notice aloud, including the line that a taxpayer impact statement "is attached to this notice." None was attached to the posted notice.[6][8]

Two Days Early

Under my own post about the notice, Jennifer Combs commented that it has "also been on city halls door since the water meeting on Tuesday," meaning Tuesday, November 10. In the same thread, Pat Jones wrote that it "was posted when I looked Wednesday morning around 7:30 on the website."[9] The certification at the bottom of that notice still says the City posted it on the bulletin board and the City's website "on Thursday, November 12, 2026 before 5 p.m.," and it is "Dated this 12th day of November."[3]

The server records support the Tuesday account.

  • The upload time. When a file is uploaded to the City's website, the file host records the time. For the November 17 agenda, it reads Tuesday, November 10, 2026, at 4:40:05 p.m. Central.[4]
  • The scan itself. The PDF is a straight scan from a Konica Minolta copier. Its embedded creation date is November 10, 2026, and it was never edited after the scan. The copier stamps the scan at 6:07 p.m., later than the upload, so its clock runs ahead; I rely on its date, not its time.[10]
  • The website's own publish date. The Agendas & Minutes page carries the date the site was last published: November 10, 2026. The page was unchanged between my captures on November 14 and November 16, so the link to the agenda has been there since November 10.[11]
  • The network cache. The content network had already served the file by Wednesday evening, November 11.[4]

By those records, the notice appears to have been online in time, at least three business days ahead, the way the Open Meetings Act requires since 2025.[12] The records have limits. They show when the file was uploaded and when the network first served it. They can't show when the paper went on the glass, or that the website stayed reachable the whole time. The newspaper notice for Tuesday's budget hearing also ran on time, on November 4, thirteen days ahead.[13][2]

Anyone can check these dates. Paste the agenda's web address into any free online "HTTP header checker" and find the line labeled "Last-Modified." To see the scan date, download the PDF, open it in Adobe Acrobat Reader, and look under File, then Properties, for "Created."

That leaves a certification signed for a date two days after the document was scanned and posted.

Page 4 of 2

The four pages of Tuesday's agenda are numbered "Page 1 of 2," "Page 2 of 2," "Page 3 of 2," and "Page 4 of 2," on the website and on the City Hall glass.[3][14]

The notice makes two promises on its first page. "A copy of the proposed budget is available on the home page of the City's website," and "A taxpayer impact statement for the median-valued homestead is attached to this notice."[3]

  • The impact statement. None is in the posted notice. The website PDF is the four agenda pages, and the Agendas & Minutes page links nothing else for this meeting.[11] On Sunday at 12:15 p.m., the four agenda pages were the only part of the notice visible through the glass.[14] Since September 1, 2025, a notice for a meeting where a city will discuss or adopt a budget must include that statement.[12]
  • The home page. The home page doesn't mention a budget. When the proposed budget isn't "clearly accessible on the home page," the same law requires a physical copy of it with the notice.[12][15] No budget was visible from outside City Hall.[14]
  • The budget itself. The proposed budget on the City Finance page is byte-for-byte the October 19 original that I wrote about in October. The updated proposal dated October 26, the one the Council was handed at the October 27 meeting, isn't on the website.[15][16]

This isn't the first notice to promise a statement that isn't there. The September 29 budget workshop notice says "The taxpayer impact statement required by that section appears at the end of this notice," and its certification says it was posted "together with the proposed budget and the taxpayer impact statement." The second and last page of that notice is the certification and the disability notice.[17] All three budget notices this fall describe a statement that none of the posted notices includes.[17][8][3]

I've also heard that an agenda doesn't have to be certified. That's correct. The Open Meetings Act sets what a notice must say and how long it must be posted, and it doesn't require a city to certify when it posted.[18] The Texas Association of Counties suggests stamping the date and time of posting on the notice, because it "may avoid a challenge to the timeliness of the notice."[19] Trinidad chose to sign a certification on each of its agendas.

Every Agenda Since August

I ran the same check on every agenda the City has posted since August. My last article counted business days from the dates the City certified.[20] The server records put several of those postings on different days.

MeetingDate the City certifiedUploaded to the websiteBusiness days online before the meeting
Tuesday, August 18Tuesday, August 11Tuesday, August 11, 10:51 a.m.4
Thursday, August 27Friday, August 21Friday, August 21, 4:59 p.m.3
Thursday, September 10Thursday, September 3Friday, September 4, 9:43 a.m.2
Tuesday, September 15Wednesday, September 9Thursday, September 10, 9:34 a.m.2
Tuesday, September 29 (budget workshop)Wednesday, September 23Friday, September 25, 11:13 a.m.1
Thursday, October 15Friday, October 9Monday, October 12, 1:15 p.m.2
Tuesday, October 27 (budget meeting)Thursday, October 22Wednesday, October 21, 3:51 p.m.3
Tuesday, November 17 (budget meeting)Thursday, November 12Tuesday, November 10, 4:40 p.m.at least 3
[4] [21]

The two budget meetings went online a day or two before the dates the City certified. Four other meetings' agendas went online one to three days after them. The September 15 and September 29 agendas are copier scans whose file names carry the scan time: each was scanned on its certified date and uploaded one or two days later.[4]

These records have limits. The file host keeps the time of the latest upload under each file name, so an earlier upload can't be ruled out, and that would only make a posting earlier. The three business days are counted from the paper posting at City Hall, and nothing here shows when paper went up for any meeting. The law requires the website copy to go up at the same time as the paper.[18]

What the records do show is that the dates the City signs don't line up with its own uploads in either direction.

The Money

Trinidad is a Type A city. Local Government Code §22.075 requires its treasurer to give the Council "a full statement of the receipts and payments," at "the governing body's first regular meeting in every quarter."[5]

Every meeting since September 15 has been a special meeting, a workshop, or a called meeting: September 18, September 29, October 15, October 27, and Tuesday. No meeting was held on the third Tuesday of October, the Council's regular date. The quarter that began October 1 has not had a regular meeting yet.[22]

That means the treasurer's statement for this quarter isn't overdue yet. The law ties it to the first regular meeting, and there hasn't been one. The fiscal year and the quarter both began October 1. It is now the middle of November, Thanksgiving is next week, and if the Council keeps its third-Tuesday schedule, the next regular date is December 15, two and a half months into the quarter. Unless a regular meeting comes sooner, the Council may see no statement of receipts and payments until then.

That sits on top of the audit. The audit of the fiscal year that ended September 30, 2025 was due to be filed by March 29, 2026, within 180 days of the year's end.[23] The Attorney General's office listed Trinidad in August among the cities sent late-audit letters, and the Mayor told me on November 13 that the audit was "Not yet" done.[24][20] A second fiscal year has now closed without the first one's audit.

The City's own agendas show the reporting falling away.[22]

  • The bills. "Monthly Bills" were on the April 21, May 19, June 18, and August 18. They haven't appeared on any agenda since August 18.
  • The financial report. A "Financial Report" was listed July 23, August 18, and September 15, and on none since. At the July 23 regular meeting, the first of that quarter, the report was a council member's summary of profit-and-loss data.[25]
  • The year-end report. The City's Code of Ordinances requires the City Administrator to give the Council, "as of the end of the fiscal year, a complete report on the finances and administrative activities of the city for the preceding year."[26] The fiscal year ended September 30. No agenda since lists that report.
  • The minutes. Tuesday's consent agenda approves the minutes of June 18, August 18, September 15, and October 15.[3]

An agenda doesn't show everything handed to the Council at a meeting, so I can't say these reports were never given. I can say they aren't in the public record, and I don't know who Trinidad's treasurer is. The same section of the City's code requires Council approval of every expense of $5,000 or more.[26]

Getting to Any of It on a Phone

Every visit to the City's website opens a pop-up with the water conversion notice and the September 16 boil water notice. It locks the page behind it, and it comes back on every new page.[27]

On phone screens shorter than about 760 pixels, the box's only close button sits above the top of the screen, and nothing else closes it. On my own iPhone, the X sat at the top edge and took repeated tries over about fifteen seconds. Then it came back on the next page. A resident in a community Facebook group asked how to get past it to find something on the City's site.[27]

Everything in this article sits behind that box: the agendas, the budget, the minutes, and the notices the City is required to post online.

The boil water notice in the pop-up is dated September 16, and it is still taped to the City Hall door. It says customers will be notified when it is lifted.[14][27] Is it still in effect?

Who Speaks for the City Online

On November 3 and 4, the City's Facebook page carried posts signed by Mayor Dennis Haws.[28]

On November 13, a resident asked who runs the page. The page answered, "myself and Marie Bannister," and the answer disappeared.[29] Late on November 14, after my article went up, councilmember-elect Jason Tatom answered on Jennifer Combs's post: "it's me and Marie Bannister."[30][20] Tatom takes his oath Tuesday. Marie Bannister is a council member and the Mayor Pro Tem.[3]

Combs explained how it started. She had asked at a water meeting for someone from the City to keep residents informed through the page. "Jason volunteered at the meeting. Then asked me to share that they would start keeping it updated. A couple days later."[30]

Combs is suing the City and Marie Bannister in federal court.[31] No agenda since August lists an item about who runs or posts to the City's Facebook page.[22] I don't know of any state law that requires a council vote on who runs a city's Facebook page. My questions are about who decided, and how residents were told.

Monday's Closure

On Sunday afternoon, the City's page announced that City Hall would be closed Monday until 1 p.m. "due to a scheduled mediation session."[28] Combs posted the same evening: "YES, I have mediation scheduled for tomorrow regarding my lawsuit against the City of Trinidad," adding that mediation "does NOT mean a settlement has been reached."[32]

The closure fell on a business day inside Tuesday's notice period. The agenda stayed readable through the glass. A settlement is a decision for the Council, and the Council can only vote on it in an open meeting under its own posted notice. Tuesday's agenda has no settlement item.[3][18]

In My Opinion

The City doesn't have to certify its agendas. It chooses to, and a certification is a signed statement of fact. When the signed date is two days after the document was scanned and posted, when the pages run to "4 of 2," and when three budget notices in a row promise an attachment that isn't there, I have to ask what else gets signed without being read.

Somebody prepared Tuesday's notice, and somebody signed it as City Secretary. Did the City Attorney, the Mayor, or the Interim City Administrator read it before it went on the door?

The Mayor has spoken for the City on its Facebook page himself. I can't find a council decision handing the page to anyone else. When was that decided, how was it communicated, and why isn't the Mayor, the face of the City, still the one doing it? Why did word of the change travel through a resident who is suing the City?

On October 27, I raised a quorum. The City's own newspaper notice for that hearing was already four days past the deadline.

Questions for Tuesday

Tuesday's meeting is at 6 p.m. at Trinidad City Hall. Visitors / Citizens Inquiry comes right after the canvass, the oaths, and the Mayor Pro Tem vote.[3] These are the questions I plan to ask, and anyone can ask them too:

  1. Who signed Tuesday's certification, and why does it say Thursday?
  2. Where is the taxpayer impact statement the notice says is attached?
  3. Which budget is the Council voting on, and why isn't it on the website?
  4. Who is the City's treasurer, and when was the last statement of receipts and payments given to the Council?
  5. Who is paying the bills, what are they, and where is the list?
  6. When is the City Administrator's year-end report on the finances due to the Council?
  7. Who decided who runs the City's Facebook page, and when?
  8. Is the September 16 boil water notice still in effect, and when will phone users be able to close the website's pop-up?

Sources

  1. 1.^ abc Public Notice, City of Trinidad: public hearing on the 2026-2027 budget, Tuesday, October 27, 2026 (opens in new tab). Athens Daily Review, via the Texas Press Association public notice archive. October 21, 2026. Published Wednesday, October 21, 2026. My capture of the archive search, November 16.
  2. 2.^ abc Texas Local Government Code, Chapter 102 (Municipal Budget) (opens in new tab). Texas Legislature. Sections 102.005, 102.006, 102.0065, and 102.007.
  3. 3.^ abcdefghi Trinidad City Council called meeting agenda, November 17, 2026 (opens in new tab). City of Trinidad. November 12, 2026. Four pages. Certification on page 3.
  4. 4.^ abcde My check of the server records for every agenda PDF on the City's website. November 16, 2026. The Last-Modified time the City's file host (Amazon S3, behind the CloudFront network) reports for each file, captured November 15 and 16. It shows when the file now at that address was uploaded. A later re-upload under the same name would replace it, so an earlier upload can't be ruled out.
  5. 5.^ ab Texas Local Government Code, Chapter 22 (Type A General-Law Municipality) (opens in new tab). Texas Legislature. Section 22.039 (quorum) and Sections 22.071 and 22.075 (officers; the treasurer's quarterly statement).
  6. 6.^ ab Livestream of the October 27, 2026 called meeting. October 27, 2026. Streamed by Jennifer Combs and later deleted. I downloaded it before the deletion and checked the quoted lines by ear.
  7. 7.^ My October 28 article: Three Aldermen Showed Up. Trinidad's Budget Meeting Needed Four. (opens in new tab) Watchtower CI. October 28, 2026.
  8. 8.^ ab Trinidad City Council called meeting agenda, October 27, 2026 (opens in new tab). City of Trinidad. October 22, 2026.
  9. 9.^ Comments under my Facebook post for "Missing in Trinidad" (opens in new tab). Facebook. November 15, 2026. Pat Jones's comment about the City's website and Jennifer Lynn Combs's reply about the City Hall door. My capture, November 16.
  10. 10.^ My check of the November 17 agenda PDF's embedded metadata. November 15, 2026. Producer: KONICA MINOLTA bizhub 227. Scanner file name SKM_22726111018070. Created and modified November 10, 2026. One revision.
  11. 11.^ ab My captures of the City's Agendas & Minutes page (opens in new tab). November 16, 2026. The page's own site data reads PublicationDate: 'Nov 10, 2026'. The page was byte-for-byte the same on November 14 and November 16. My October 25 copy read 'Oct 21, 2026.'
  12. 12.^ abc H.B. 1522, 89th Legislature, Regular Session (enrolled) (opens in new tab). Texas Legislature. September 1, 2025. Government Code Section 551.043(a) and (c): three business days, and what a budget meeting notice must include.
  13. 13.^ Public Notice, City of Trinidad: public hearing on the 2026-2027 budget, Tuesday, November 17, 2026 (opens in new tab). Athens Daily Review. November 4, 2026. Published Wednesday, November 4, 2026 (Texas Press Association notice 975488). My captures, November 16.
  14. 14.^ abcd My photos of the City Hall entrance postings. November 15, 2026. 12:15 p.m. The four pages of the November 17 agenda, facing out on the glass. No impact statement and no budget visible from outside. The September 16 boil water notice is also posted.
  15. 15.^ ab My captures of the City's home page and City Finance page (opens in new tab). November 16, 2026. Home page: no link to or mention of a budget (also on November 14). City Finance: "PROPOSED CITY BUDGET 2026-2027" (budget_2026-2027.pdf), uploaded October 19, byte-for-byte the copy I saved October 25.
  16. 16.^ Updated FY2026-2027 Budget Proposal, dated October 26, 2026. City of Trinidad. October 26, 2026. The copy handed out at the October 27 meeting. Not posted on the City's website as of November 16.
  17. 17.^ ab Trinidad City Council budget workshop agenda, September 29, 2026 (opens in new tab). City of Trinidad. September 23, 2026. Two pages: the agenda, then the certification and the disability notice.
  18. 18.^ abc Texas Government Code, Chapter 551 (Open Meetings Act) (opens in new tab). Texas Legislature. Sections 551.041, 551.043, 551.050, 551.056, and 551.102.
  19. 19.^ Open Meetings Act (December 2025, updated May 2026) (opens in new tab). Texas Association of Counties. Page 12, on stamping the date and time of posting.
  20. 20.^ abc My November 14 article: Missing in Trinidad: A Business Day, an Audit, and a City Reply (opens in new tab). Watchtower CI. November 14, 2026.
  21. 21.^ Trinidad City Council Agendas & Minutes (opens in new tab). City of Trinidad. Every agenda and set of minutes posted for 2026.
  22. 22.^ abc Trinidad City Council agendas and minutes, January through November 2026 (opens in new tab). City of Trinidad. "Monthly Bills" on the consent agenda April 21, May 19, June 18, and August 18. "Financial Report" listed July 23, August 18, and September 15. Meeting titles as printed on each agenda.
  23. 23.^ Texas Local Government Code, Chapter 103 (Audit of Municipal Finances) (opens in new tab). Texas Legislature. Sections 103.001 and 103.003: an annual audit, filed within 180 days after the end of the fiscal year.
  24. 24.^ Attorney General Ken Paxton Sends Letters Prohibiting More Than 110 Cities From Illegally Raising Taxes on Texans (opens in new tab). Office of the Texas Attorney General. August 17, 2026. Lists Trinidad among the cities sent violation determination letters under the late-audit law.
  25. 25.^ Trinidad City Council minutes, July 23, 2026 (opens in new tab). City of Trinidad. Financial Report: a council member "presented a financial summary based on Profit & Loss data from October 2025 through June 2026."
  26. 26.^ ab City of Trinidad Code of Ordinances, Section 31.019 (City Administrator) (opens in new tab). American Legal Publishing. Ord. 97-, passed March 11, 1997. The online code is current through Ord. 2022-002 (April 19, 2022).
  27. 27.^ abc My test of the City website's notice pop-up. November 16, 2026. Six fresh loads at different screen sizes, screen-recorded, November 14 (11:37 p.m.), and a screen recording on my own iPhone, November 16. A resident's question about the pop-up in a community Facebook group was relayed to me by Renee Weaver.
  28. 28.^ ab Trinidad Tx City Hall Facebook page (opens in new tab). Facebook. Posts signed by Mayor Dennis Haws on November 3 and 4. The November 15 post closing City Hall until 1 p.m. Monday "due to a scheduled mediation session." My captures.
  29. 29.^ Facebook notification of the Trinidad Tx City Hall page's reply to Renee Weaver. November 13, 2026. Screenshot taken at 5:34 p.m. Provided to me by Renee Weaver.
  30. 30.^ ab Comments under Jennifer Lynn Combs's November 13 post sharing the City Hall page (opens in new tab). Facebook. November 15, 2026. Jason Tatom's reply (about 9:17 p.m. November 14) and Jennifer Combs's replies (November 15). My captures, 10:17 to 11:30 a.m. November 15.
  31. 31.^ My May 26 article: Still Talking to Chief Gregory: An Update on Trinidad PD and the Side You May Be Missing (opens in new tab). Watchtower CI. May 26, 2026. Jennifer Combs's federal lawsuit against Chief Gregory, Officer Cameron Beckham, Marie Bannister, and the City of Trinidad, filed May 19, 2026.
  32. 32.^ Jennifer Lynn Combs, posts about the November 16 mediation (opens in new tab). Facebook. November 15, 2026. Also https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1CgLFx86k3/. My captures, November 16.

Use Google? Add Watchtower as a preferred source (opens in new tab) to see more of my stories in Top Stories.

Free to republish with credit. See the terms

Know something about this story?

Documents, dates, and names are where every investigation starts. Tips are confidential, and anonymous tips are welcome.

Send a Tip

This reporting is reader-funded: no paywalls, no ads, no sponsors. Chip in any amount.


Read Next

TrinidadOpinion

Trinidad Faced Conflict All Year. It's Still Standing.

Trinidad spent 2026 having hard conversations in public, and it's still here. Before Tuesday's election: what still needs fixing, what the Council has gotten right, and what I'm asking of council members, candidates and voters in Trinidad and around the lake.

Ron Helms · 8 min read